In what appears to be an effort of geopolitical muscle flexing, Google has announced on its blog its intention to cease its activities in China, or, to put it in their own words, to review Google’s business operations in China. Google claims to have evidence of several attempts of the Chinese Government to hack Gmail accounts of human rights activists, as well as several other violations of privacy and censorship actions, all leading up to Google’s decision to reconsider their involvement in the Chinese market.

While Internet censorship in China has been well documented since 2006 (see this image for a comparison of Google.com vs Google.cn results for “tianaman”) and I have nothing against Google playing the moral crusader it’s not, I do, however, have a few definitive issue with the context of this decision…

1. The Hero Of The Story Was Actually An Accomplice.
That’s right, the Chinese Government enforces hardcore censorship, strictly controls access to information and keeps a tab on the country’s Internet users. But here’s the catch: not only was Google aware of this policy, but they agreed to it and molded their business model to suit China’s regulations, when they first established their offices in China. And Google doesn’t even make a secret of it, acknowledging it bluntly in the official statement: We launched Google.cn in January 2006 in the belief that the benefits of increased access to information for people in China and a more open Internet outweighed our discomfort in agreeing to censor some results. So Google actually agreed to abide by the unique moral standards of the Chinese Government and now they admit it, like it were a minor concession. Which brings us to point two of my discourse…

2. The Dr. Mengele Arguement
Let’s take a closer look at that line from the official statement, shall we?
The belief that the benefits of increased access to information for people in China and a more open Internet outweighed our discomfort in agreeing to censor some results.
All right, fair enough… Google’s executive decision to go ahead with the launch of Google.cn, despite Government censorship stands to reason, being for the benefit of the general concept of access to information, right? Wrong! Consider, if you will, the implications and the undertone of that quote. Stripping the text down to its essence and interpreting it stripped of Google’s charming arguement of information liberalization, we’re basically given to understand that Google contributes to the Government’s efforts to limit people’s access to information. No, I’m sorry, I do not believe that, despite “some minor censorship efforts”, the people were still the beneficiaries. Google’s statement is underplaying the role of censorship, to cover its own arse. The underlying tone is ridiculous in itself; there is no such thing as liberal censorship. Trying to downplay Google’s contribution to Chinese censorship, implying the “greater good” is like trying to excuse Dr. Mengele of torturing Jews, by invoking his contribution to the field of Medicine.

3. Why Google’s Company Philosophy Is Just Corporate BS

Like we would expect from Google, it aggrandizes itself as the Messiah of the Internet. And on the seventh day, Google layed forth ten laws it holds sacred. And this Decalogue can be read on the Google Corporate Information Page. Needless to say, these arguements are not at all watertight. In fact, Google violates most of them on a routine basis. But, for the sake of arguement, let’s see how Google’s Chinese exploits measure up to some of its own guiding principles…
Now the first line of these commandments is a quote by the prophet Saint Larry Page, stating the perfect Search Engine would understand exactly what you mean and give you back exactly what you want. All right, so basically, if I were, let’s say, Chinese and I were to google, I don’t know, tianaman square (or 天安門廣場 in Traditional Chinese), in the interest of information, the SERPS would return content dealing with the 1989 protest and massacre, right? Well, not exactly, but it would give me bright propaganda images with the great Tianaman monument, communist flags and proud citizens. Again, if I were to google Chinese communism (or 中國共產主義 in Traditional Chinese), I would get images of human rights protesters, popular uproar and people shot in the streets, similar to the Google.com results, right? Well, actually no, I would get 10 pages worth of propaganda posters, artistic depictions of socialist folk heroes and so forth on Google.cn. All right, yeah, Google definitely understands me and delivers exactly what I want. I suddenly feel the urge to get a below-minimum-wage job at a sweatshop. Thanks, Google!

Commandment 1: Focus on the user and all else will follow. So, basically, if you’re a simple Chinese citizen, with the Government keeping an eye on your everyday life, you are being served Government-controlled information. In this respect, Google lives up to its promise, for sure.
Commandment 4: Democracy on the web works. Right, umm… moving on…
Commandment 6: You can make money without being evil. All right, err… moving on… guys, you’re making it hard on yourselves…
Commandment 7: There’s always more information out there. Right, you’re just not entitled to it, because you live in a communist country, so, there you go. Sucks to be you.

4. The Great Asian Conspiracy
Everybody likes a good conspiracy theory from time to time.  Hell, even you do, admit it! The problem is, this time I don’t have enough facts or the necessary patience to actually devise a clever world domination plot for the Google Chinese Crisis, so I am only going to list some weird coincidences and leave it up to my readers to make some sense of it all in the comments section…

First of all, the Google Chinese Crisis comes one day after Baidu.cn was attacked by hackers. So? Big deal! Well, Baidu.cn is Google’s main competitor. So much in fact, that it hogs around 75% of the Chinese Search market, being one of the last real competitors for Big Brother Google in the world today.  Now I’m not trying to imply Google actually commissioned the attack on Baidu, I’m just guessing that nobody at Googleplex actually wept for Baidu the day of the transgression. Furthermore, ChinaDaily notes the attack was not carried out against the Baidu server, but the US – based domain name register. Naturally, any fingers pointing at Google would be preposterous, as the sophisticated attack has already been claimed by some punks from a random organization, namely the “Iranian Cyber Army“… ah-hah! Now I get it… uhhh…

All right, the attack on Baidu and Google’s sudden decision to renegotiate its terms with the Chinese Government coincided. Granted. Besides, some minor-league email hacking attempt is a totally believable excuse to cease all operations in the top Internet country of the world, right? But Twitter has been buzzing lately with similar, albeit minor coincidences… first, someone noted the website Baidu.tw redirecting to Google Taiwan and Twitter has been flooded with comments on this issue. Granted, Google’s implication is highly unlikely, as a simple Whois query will point to the owner of the website, whose email address is registered to some obscure Chinese platform, http://21cn.com. Subsequently, Yahoo! Japan president, Masahiro Inoue said Google is nothing special, commenting on several services offered by the Big G.

I will admit, the above information does in no way justify a conspiracy theory and suspecting Google’s implication would be sheer speculation. And the goal of this article isn’t to blame Google for world hunger and WWII (although I might consider that for a future post). I am merely pointing out that “things are happening”. The Search market isn’t just some tiny business in the back pocket of a geek toy, called the Internet. It has grown to huge proportions, so much that today we are talking about the geopolitical implications of a Search Engine’s actions, as economic leaders anxiously await the results of a Search Engine’s negotiations with the Chinese Government. Just let this thought sink in for a moment, then meditate, if you will, on how far the Search business has evolved over the last decade. To sum it all up, the times, they are a-changin’.

Tell the world about this post:

Close Bookmark and Share This Page

Save to Browser Favorites / Bookmarks

Ask backflip blinklist BlogBookmark Bloglines BlogMarks Blogsvine BuddyMarks BUMPzee! CiteULike co.mments Connotea del.icio.us

Digg diigo DotNetKicks DropJack dzone Facebook Fark Faves Feed Me Links Friendsite folkd.com Furl Google

Hugg Jamespot Jeqq Kaboodle kirtsy linkaGoGo LinkedIn LinksMarker Ma.gnolia Mister Wong Mixx MySpace MyWeb

Netvouz Newsvine oneview OnlyWire PlugIM Propeller Reddit Rojo Segnalo Shoutwire Simpy Slashdot Sphere

Sphinn Spurl Squidoo StumbleUpon Technorati ThisNext Twitter Webride Windows Live Worlds Movies Yahoo!

Email This to a Friend

Copy HTML: 

 If you like this then please subscribe to the RSS Feed.

Powered by Bookmarkify™

More »

Powered by Bookmarkify™

Tags: baidu, censorship, chinese search market, geopolitics, Google, google china, iranian cyber army, news